Head-to-head record against Bury: 28 meetings, W12 D7 L9 →
2024–25
- 1 April 2025Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 1 : Sky BetHome1stDrawn 0–0
- 14 December 2024Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 1 : Sky BetAway1stWon 4–1
- 28 June 2024Aylesbury UnitedFriendly : TrialistsNeutralUnoff.Drawn 3–3
2023–24
- 13 April 2024Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 1 : Sky BetAway1stWon 2–0
- 9 December 2023Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 1 : Sky BetHome1stLost 0–1
2022–23
- 25 February 2023Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 1 : Sky BetAway1stLost 0–2
- 13 August 2022Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 1 : Sky BetHome1stLost 1–2
- 22 July 2022Aylesbury UnitedFriendly : TrialistsAwayUnoff.Drawn 1–1
2021–22
- 8 February 2022Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 1 : Sky BetHome1stDrawn 0–0
- 28 September 2021Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 1 : Sky BetAway1stWon 2–1
- 23 July 2021Aylesbury UnitedFriendly : TrialistsAwayUnoff.Won 3–1
2019–20
- 2 November 2019Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 1 : Sky BetHome1stWon 1–0
2018–19
- 16 March 2019Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 1 : Sky BetAway1stLost 1–2
- 24 November 2018Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 1 : Sky BetHome1stWon 3–2
2014–15
- 14 March 2015Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 2 : Sky BetHome1stWon 1–0
- 17 January 2015BuryFootball League : League 2 : Sky BetAway1stDrawn 1–1
- 28 December 2014Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 2 : Sky BetAway1stDrawn 0–0
- 6 September 2014BuryFootball League : League 2 : Sky BetHome1stDrawn 0–0
2013–14
- 1 February 2014BuryFootball League : League 2 : Sky BetAway1stLost 0–1
- 26 October 2013BuryFootball League : League 2 : Sky BetHome1stLost 1–2
2011–12
- 17 March 2012BuryFootball League : League 1 : npowerAway1stWon 4–1
- 20 August 2011BuryFootball League : League 1 : npowerHome1stLost 0–2
2010–11
- 30 April 2011BuryFootball League : League 2 : npowerAway1stWon 3–1
- 19 March 2011Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 2 : npowerAway1stDrawn 1–1
- 11 December 2010BuryFootball League : League 2 : npowerHome1stWon 1–0
- 25 September 2010Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 2 : npowerHome1stDrawn 2–2
2008–09
- 28 March 2009Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 2 : Coca ColaHome1stDrawn 1–1
- 3 January 2009BuryFootball League : League 2 : Coca ColaHome1stWon 2–1
- 20 December 2008Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 2 : Coca ColaAway1stWon 1–0
- 7 October 2008Shrewsbury TownFootball League Trophy : Johnstone's Paint · Round 2Home1stLost 0–7