Head-to-head record against Cookham: 12 meetings, W7 D2 L1 →
1938–39
- 22 October 1938Cookham DeanHigh Wycombe Challenge Cup (2) · Round 1Away2ndWon 7–6
1927–28
- 21 January 1928CookhamHigh Wycombe Challenge Cup (2) · 2RHome2ndWon 12–0
- 26 November 1927CookhamHigh Wycombe Challenge Cup (2) · Round 2Home2ndAbandoned
1920–21
- 19 February 1921CookhamMaidenhead Norfolkian Charity Cup (2) · Round 2Home2ndWon 4–0
- 1 January 1921CookhamMaidenhead Norfolkian Charity Cup (2) · Round 2Away2ndAbandoned
1909–10
- 23 April 1910Cookham UnitedSouth Bucks & East Berks Junior League (2)Away2ndWon 2–0
- 16 April 1910Cookham UnitedSouth Bucks & East Berks Junior League (2)Home2ndWon 5–1
- 2 April 1910Cookham UnitedHigh Wycombe Challenge Cup (2) · FNeutral2ndWon 2–0
1908–09
- 23 January 1909CookhamSouth Bucks & East Berks Junior League (2)Home2ndWon 3–0
- 3 October 1908CookhamMaidenhead Norfolkian Charity Cup (2) · Round 1Away2ndLost 1–4
- 3 October 1908Cookham UnitedSouth Bucks & East Berks Junior League (2)Away2ndLost 2–6
1907–08
- 22 February 1908Cookham UnitedSouth Bucks & East Berks Junior League (2)Away2ndLost 1–7
- 16 November 1907Cookham UnitedSouth Bucks & East Berks Junior League (2)Home2ndWon 4–1
1906–07
- 20 April 1907CookhamSouth Bucks & East Berks Junior League (2)Home2ndDrawn 1–1
- 23 March 1907CookhamHigh Wycombe Challenge Cup (2) · S/F RHome2ndWon 2–1
- 16 March 1907CookhamHigh Wycombe Challenge Cup (2) · S/FAway2ndDrawn 0–0
- 22 September 1906CookhamSouth Bucks & East Berks Junior League (2)Away2ndWon 4–1
1905–06
- 31 March 1906CookhamSouth Bucks & East Berks Junior League (2)Home2ndWon 6–1
- 3 February 1906CookhamSouth Bucks & East Berks Junior League (2)Away2ndWon 2–0
1895–96
- 19 October 1895Cookham DeanBerks & Bucks Junior Cup (2) · Round 1Home2ndWon 4–2