Head-to-head record against Excelsior: 1 meetings, W1 D0 L0 →
1977–78
- 30 May 1978ExcelsiorFriendly : Tour (U)AwayUnoff.Won 7–1
1894–95
- 23 March 1895Bourne End ExcelsiorSouth Bucks & East Berks Junior League (2)Away2ndWon 5–1
- 29 September 1894Bourne End ExcelsiorSouth Bucks & East Berks Junior League (1)Home1stWon 11–0
1893–94
- 30 December 1893Bourne End ExcelsiorHigh Wycombe Challenge Cup (1) · Round 2Away1stWon 1–0