Head-to-head record against Maidenhead Reserves: 45 meetings, W28 D3 L13 →
1899–00
- 23 September 1899Maidenhead Norfolkians ReservesSouth Bucks & East Berks Junior League (2)Home2ndWon 2–0
1898–99
- 3 December 1898Maidenhead ReservesSouth Bucks & East Berks Junior League (2)Home2ndWon 4–0
- 17 September 1898Maidenhead ReservesSouth Bucks & East Berks Junior League (2)Away2ndWon 4–1
1897–98
- 19 February 1898Maidenhead ReservesSouth Bucks & East Berks Junior League (2)Home2ndLost 1–2
- 1 January 1898Maidenhead ReservesSouth Bucks & East Berks Junior League (2)Away2ndWon 3–2
1896–97
- 13 March 1897Maidenhead ReservesSouth Bucks & East Berks Junior League (2)Home2ndWon 1–0
- 25 December 1896Maidenhead ReservesSouth Bucks & East Berks Junior League (2)Away2ndLost 2–3
1894–95
- 18 April 1895Maidenhead ReservesSouth Bucks & East Berks Junior League (2)Away2ndLost 2–3
- 24 November 1894Maidenhead ReservesBerks & Bucks Junior Cup (2) · Round 2Away2ndResult unconfirmed
- 3 November 1894Maidenhead ReservesSouth Bucks & East Berks Junior League (1)Home1stWon 6–0
- 15 September 1894Maidenhead ReservesFriendly : 1st TeamAway1stWon 4–1
1891–92
- 16 January 1892Maidenhead ReservesMaidenhead Norfolkian Charity Cup (1) · Round 2Away1stLost 0–1
- 3 October 1891Maidenhead ReservesFriendly : 1st TeamHome1stDrawn 1–1