Head-to-head record against Newbury Town: 9 meetings, W5 D2 L2 →
1985–86
- 13 August 1985Newbury TownFriendly : 2nd TeamAway2ndWon 3–0
1981–82
- 7 October 1981Newbury TownBerks & Bucks Senior Cup (1) · Round 1Away1stWon 5–1
1955–56
- 10 March 1956Newbury TownBerks & Bucks Senior Cup (1) · S/FNeutral1stWon 3–0
1954–55
- 26 March 1955Newbury TownBerks & Bucks Senior Cup (1) · S/FNeutral1stWon 3–1
1925–26
- 19 September 1925Newbury TownF.A. Challenge Cup · PrelHome1stLost 1–6
1924–25
- 28 March 1925Newbury TownBerks & Bucks Senior Cup (1) · S/F RepNeutral1stWon 1–0
- 7 March 1925Newbury TownBerks & Bucks Senior Cup (1) · S/FNeutral1stDrawn 0–0
1919–20
- 14 February 1920Newbury TownGreat Western Suburban LeagueHome2ndDrawn 3–3
- 6 December 1919Newbury TownGreat Western Suburban LeagueAway2ndLost 1–3