Head-to-head record against Oxford City Reserves: 81 meetings, W39 D12 L30 →
1967–68
- 11 April 1968Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesHome2ndDrawn 1–1
- 18 November 1967Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesAway2ndDrawn 2–2
1966–67
- 8 April 1967Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesHome2ndWon 2–1
- 11 March 1967Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesAway2ndDrawn 1–1
1965–66
- 23 April 1966Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesAway2ndDrawn 2–2
- 4 December 1965Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesHome2ndWon 6–2
1964–65
- 16 January 1965Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesAway2ndLost 0–5
- 26 December 1964Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesHome2ndLost 0–1
1963–64
- 12 September 1963Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesAway2ndLost 3–5
- 5 September 1963Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesHome2ndWon 5–3
1962–63
- 17 November 1962Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesAway2ndLost 0–2
- 20 October 1962Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesHome2ndLost 1–3
1961–62
- 3 February 1962Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesHome2ndLost 3–4
- 9 December 1961Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesAway2ndWon 3–0
1960–61
- 25 April 1961Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesAway2ndWon 3–2
- 31 March 1961Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesHome2ndDrawn 2–2
1959–60
- 18 April 1960Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesHome2ndWon 5–2
- 26 December 1959Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesAway2ndWon 7–1
1958–59
- 14 March 1959Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesHome2ndWon 4–3
- 6 December 1958Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesAway2ndWon 3–1
1957–58
- 22 April 1958Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesAway2ndDrawn 1–1
- 4 September 1957Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesHome2ndWon 9–2
1956–57
- 8 December 1956Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesHome2ndWon 2–1
- 5 September 1956Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesAway2ndLost 2–3
1955–56
- 31 December 1955Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesAway2ndLost 1–2
- 17 September 1955Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesHome2ndDrawn 4–4
1954–55
- 5 March 1955Oxford City ReservesReading Senior Cup · S/FNeutral2ndWon 6–0
- 8 September 1954Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesHome2ndWon 6–0
- 1 September 1954Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesAway2ndLost 1–2
1953–54
- 9 September 1953Oxford City ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesHome2ndWon 3–0