Head-to-head record against Sutton United: 83 meetings, W31 D22 L29 →
1973–74
- 29 September 1973Sutton UnitedRothmans Isthmian LeagueAway1stWon 2–0
1972–73
- 6 January 1973Sutton UnitedIsthmian LeagueHome1stWon 3–1
- 19 August 1972Sutton UnitedIsthmian LeagueAway1stWon 2–0
1971–72
- 29 April 1972Sutton UnitedIsthmian LeagueHome1stWon 3–0
- 30 October 1971Sutton UnitedIsthmian LeagueAway1stWon 2–1
1970–71
- 17 April 1971Sutton UnitedIsthmian LeagueAway1stWon 1–0
- 29 August 1970Sutton UnitedIsthmian LeagueHome1stWon 4–0
1969–70
- 18 April 1970Sutton UnitedIsthmian LeagueHome1stDrawn 2–2
- 16 August 1969Sutton UnitedIsthmian LeagueAway1stWon 2–1
1968–69
- 19 April 1969Sutton UnitedIsthmian LeagueHome1stLost 0–1
- 22 March 1969Sutton United ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesHome2ndWon 2–1
- 2 November 1968Sutton United ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesAway2ndLost 0–3
- 14 September 1968Sutton UnitedIsthmian LeagueAway1stWon 1–0
1967–68
- 22 April 1968Sutton UnitedIsthmian LeagueHome1stLost 1–2
- 16 December 1967Sutton UnitedIsthmian LeagueAway1stLost 1–4
- 25 November 1967Sutton United ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesHome2ndWon 3–1
- 21 October 1967Sutton United ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesAway2ndDrawn 3–3
1966–67
- 28 January 1967Sutton UnitedIsthmian LeagueHome1stDrawn 1–1
- 17 December 1966Sutton UnitedIsthmian LeagueAway1stDrawn 1–1
- 29 October 1966Sutton United ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesAway2ndLost 0–1
- 3 September 1966Sutton United ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesHome2ndLost 2–4
1965–66
- 18 December 1965Sutton UnitedIsthmian LeagueHome1stWon 3–2
- 25 September 1965Sutton UnitedIsthmian LeagueAway1stDrawn 1–1
1964–65
- 13 March 1965Sutton UnitedIsthmian LeagueHome1stDrawn 1–1
- 9 January 1965Sutton United ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesAway2ndDrawn 1–1
- 31 October 1964Sutton United ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesHome2ndLost 1–3
- 17 September 1964Sutton UnitedIsthmian LeagueAway1stLost 1–2
1963–64
- 11 April 1964Sutton United ReservesIsthmian League - ReservesAway2ndWon 2–0
- 8 April 1964Sutton UnitedIsthmian LeagueHome1stLost 3–5
- 2 November 1963Sutton UnitedIsthmian LeagueAway1stLost 1–2