Head-to-head record against Bury: 28 meetings, W12 D7 L9 →
2007–08
- 22 September 2007Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 2 : Coca ColaHomeDrawn 1–1
- 25 August 2007BuryFootball League : League 2 : Coca ColaHomeWon 1–0
2006–07
- 7 April 2007Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 2 : Coca ColaHomeDrawn 1–1
- 17 February 2007BuryFootball League : League 2 : Coca ColaAwayWon 4–0
- 4 November 2006Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 2 : Coca ColaAwayDrawn 0–0
- 19 August 2006BuryFootball League : League 2 : Coca ColaHomeWon 3–0
2005–06
- 11 March 2006Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 2 : Coca ColaHomeWon 2–0
- 17 December 2005BuryFootball League : League 2 : Coca ColaAwayLost 1–2
- 27 August 2005Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 2 : Coca ColaAwayDrawn 1–1
- 20 August 2005BuryFootball League : League 2 : Coca ColaHomeWon 4–0
2004–05
- 16 April 2005BuryFootball League : League 2 : Coca ColaHomeLost 1–2
- 29 January 2005Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 2 : Coca ColaAwayWon 1–0
- 7 December 2004BuryFootball League : League 2 : Coca ColaAwayDrawn 2–2
- 2 October 2004Shrewsbury TownFootball League : League 2 : Coca ColaHomeDrawn 1–1
2001–02
- 2 March 2002BuryFootball League : Division 2 : NationwideHomeLost 0–2
- 2 October 2001BuryFootball League : Division 2 : NationwideAwayDrawn 1–1
2000–01
- 28 April 2001BuryFootball League : Division 2 : NationwideAwayDrawn 1–1
- 11 November 2000BuryFootball League : Division 2 : NationwideHomeWon 2–1
1999–00
- 26 February 2000BuryFootball League : Division 2 : NationwideHomeWon 3–0
- 18 September 1999BuryFootball League : Division 2 : NationwideAwayLost 0–2
1998–99
- 8 December 1998Shrewsbury TownFootball League Trophy : Auto Windscreen · Round 1AwayWon 1–0
1996–97
- 31 March 1997BuryFootball League : Division 2 : EndsleighAwayLost 0–2
- 29 March 1997Shrewsbury TownFootball League : Division 2 : EndsleighHomeWon 3–0
- 27 August 1996BuryFootball League : Division 2 : EndsleighHomeLost 0–1
- 18 August 1996Shrewsbury TownFootball League : Division 2 : EndsleighAwayDrawn 1–1
1995–96
- 9 March 1996Shrewsbury TownFootball League : Division 2 : EndsleighAwayDrawn 1–1
- 23 December 1995Shrewsbury TownFootball League : Division 2 : EndsleighHomeWon 2–0
1994–95
- 11 February 1995Shrewsbury TownFootball League : Division 2 : EndsleighAwayDrawn 2–2
- 29 November 1994Shrewsbury TownFootball League Trophy : Auto Windscreen · Round 2AwayLost 0–2
- 1 November 1994Shrewsbury TownFootball League : Division 2 : EndsleighHomeWon 1–0