Head-to-head record against Bury: 28 meetings, W12 D7 L9 →
1955–56
- 10 March 1956Newbury TownBerks & Bucks Senior Cup (1) · S/FNeutralWon 3–0
- 22 October 1955Banbury SpencerF.A. Challenge Cup · 3QAwayWon 2–1
1954–55
- 26 March 1955Newbury TownBerks & Bucks Senior Cup (1) · S/FNeutralWon 3–1
- 11 September 1954Aylesbury UnitedF.A. Challenge Cup · PrelAwayWon 1–0
1953–54
- 12 September 1953Banbury SpencerF.A. Challenge Cup · PrelAwayLost 1–2
1951–52
- 27 October 1951Aylesbury UnitedF.A. Challenge Cup · 3QHomeLost 1–2
1950–51
- 18 October 1950Aylesbury UnitedF.A. Challenge Cup · 2Q RepHomeWon 2–0
- 14 October 1950Aylesbury UnitedF.A. Challenge Cup · 2QAwayDrawn 2–2
1946–47
- 15 February 1947Aylesbury UnitedBerks & Bucks Senior Cup (1) · Round 3HomeWon 4–2
1939–40
- 9 December 1939NewburyBerks & Bucks Senior Cup (1) · S/FHomeWon 6–2
1937–38
- 29 January 1938Aylesbury UnitedBerks & Bucks Senior Cup (1) · Round 2HomeWon 3–1
1936–37
- 3 October 1936Banbury SpencerF.A. Challenge Cup · 1QAwayWon 3–1
- 19 September 1936Aylesbury UnitedF.A. Challenge Cup · PrelAwayWon 2–1
1934–35
- 22 April 1935Aylesbury UnitedBerks & Bucks Senior Cup (1) · FNeutralWon 3–0
- 27 September 1934Aylesbury UnitedBerks & Bucks Benevolent Cup · S/FAwayLost 1–2
- 15 September 1934Aylesbury UnitedF.A. Challenge Cup · PrelAwayLost 0–3
1933–34
- 28 October 1933Aylesbury UnitedBucks Charity Cup (1) · FHomeWon 6–1
1928–29
- 15 December 1928Aylesbury UnitedF.A. Amateur Cup · Round 1HomeWon 3–1
1926–27
- 6 November 1926Banbury United (Combined 1926)Oxford Hospital Cup · Round 1AwayWon 3–0
1925–26
- 17 October 1925Aylesbury UnitedOxford Hospital Cup · Round 1HomeWon 9–0
- 19 September 1925Newbury TownF.A. Challenge Cup · PrelHomeLost 1–6
1924–25
- 28 March 1925Newbury TownBerks & Bucks Senior Cup (1) · S/F RepNeutralWon 1–0
- 7 March 1925Newbury TownBerks & Bucks Senior Cup (1) · S/FNeutralDrawn 0–0
1921–22
- 26 November 1921Aylesbury UnitedBerks & Bucks Senior Cup (1) · Round 1HomeWon 5–1
1920–21
- 23 April 1921Aylesbury UnitedSpartan LeagueAwayWon 3–1
- 29 January 1921Cubitts (Aylesbury)Berks & Bucks Senior Cup (1) · Round 2HomeWon 4–0
- 18 December 1920Aylesbury UnitedSpartan LeagueHomeWon 7–0
1919–20
- 14 February 1920Aylesbury UnitedBucks Charity Cup (1) · S/F RepAwayWon 4–0
- 22 November 1919Aylesbury UnitedSpartan LeagueHomeWon 4–0
- 18 October 1919Aylesbury UnitedSpartan LeagueAwayWon 5–2