Head-to-head record against Casuals: 41 meetings, W16 D10 L15 →
1925–26
- 27 February 1926CasualsIsthmian LeagueAwayDrawn 1–1
- 10 October 1925CasualsIsthmian LeagueHomeLost 1–2
1924–25
- 17 January 1925CasualsIsthmian LeagueHomeLost 0–3
- 11 October 1924CasualsIsthmian LeagueAwayLost 3–5
1923–24
- 3 May 1924CasualsIsthmian LeagueAwayLost 2–6
- 5 April 1924CasualsIsthmian LeagueHomeWon 5–4
1922–23
- 18 April 1923CasualsIsthmian LeagueAwayDrawn 2–2
- 2 December 1922CasualsIsthmian LeagueHomeLost 3–4
1921–22
- 12 November 1921CasualsIsthmian LeagueAwayWon 6–2
- 10 September 1921CasualsIsthmian LeagueHomeWon 7–2
1896–97
- 30 January 1897CasualsF.A. Amateur Cup · Round 1HomeLost 3–5