Biggest wins
- Won 14–0Booker1 December 1945 · Home · High Wycombe Challenge Cup (2)
- Won 13–0Daws Hill United24 September 1949 · Away · High Wycombe Challenge Cup (2)
- Won 13–0Wimbledon Reserves12 October 1957 · Home · Isthmian League - Reserves
- Won 10–0Tufnell Park Reserves7 May 1947 · Home · Isthmian League - Reserves
- Won 10–0Bournemouth Youth20 March 1973 · Home · Friendly : 2nd Team
- Won 10–0Maltese Falcons9 May 1977 · Home · Friendly : 2nd Team
- Won 10–0Geneva College, Florida20 August 1985 · Home · Friendly : 2nd Team
- Won 10–1Woking Reserves17 November 1951 · Home · Isthmian League - Reserves
- Won 10–1Uganda FA XI29 August 1956 · Home · Friendly : 2nd Team
- Won 10–1Corinthian Casuals Reserves28 March 1981 · Away · Suburban League
Heaviest defeats
- Lost 0–9Woking Reserves19 March 1949 · Away · Isthmian League - Reserves
- Lost 0–9Fulham3 February 1999 · Home · Avon Insurance Combination
- Lost 1–9Walthamstow Avenue Reserves17 January 1948 · Away · Isthmian League - Reserves
- Lost 3–10Stokenchurch9 February 1946 · Away · Berks & Bucks Junior Cup (2)
- Lost 2–9Wembley Reserves31 December 1983 · Away · Suburban League
- Lost 0–7Wimbledon Reserves3 May 1961 · Home · Isthmian League - Reserves
- Lost 0–7Ipswich Town29 March 2000 · Away · Avon Insurance Combination
- Lost 1–7Wimbledon Reserves22 October 1960 · Away · Isthmian League - Reserves
- Lost 1–7Queens Park Rangers15 March 2000 · Away · Avon Insurance Combination
- Lost 0–6Wimbledon Reserves4 September 1948 · Away · Isthmian League - Reserves
Most goals in a match
- Lost 6–9Army6 October 1945 · Home · Friendly : 2nd Team
- Won 14–0Booker1 December 1945 · Home · High Wycombe Challenge Cup (2)
- Drawn 7–7Marlow Reserves2 March 1946 · Away · Friendly : 2nd Team
- Lost 3–10Stokenchurch9 February 1946 · Away · Berks & Bucks Junior Cup (2)
- Won 13–0Daws Hill United24 September 1949 · Away · High Wycombe Challenge Cup (2)
- Won 13–0Wimbledon Reserves12 October 1957 · Home · Isthmian League - Reserves
- Won 9–3Wooburn Athletic29 March 1947 · Neutral · High Wycombe Challenge Cup (2)
- Won 7–5Downley Albion27 December 1947 · Away · High Wycombe Challenge Cup (2)
- Lost 4–8Romford Reserves28 August 1948 · Away · Isthmian League - Reserves
- Lost 4–8Ilford Reserves16 October 1948 · Away · Isthmian League - Reserves
Highest attendances
- 10,000Chelmsford City25 April 1983 · Neutral · Gigi Peronace Challenge Cup
- 10,000Chelsea13 July 2005 · Home · Friendly : 2nd Team
- 8,200Chelsea31 July 2002 · Home · Friendly : 2nd Team
- 8,018Tottenham Hotspur21 July 2001 · Home · Friendly : 2nd Team
- 7,500Uganda FA XI29 August 1956 · Home · Friendly : 2nd Team
- 6,975Aston Villa18 July 1997 · Home · Friendly : 2nd Team
- 5,820Chelsea29 July 2010 · Home · Friendly : 2nd Team
- 5,534Flackwell Heath26 March 1948 · Neutral · High Wycombe Challenge Cup (2)
- 5,389Tottenham Hotspur19 July 2003 · Home · Friendly : 2nd Team
- 5,072Celtic8 October 2002 · Home · Friendly : 2nd Team
Longest runs
Consecutive results in all competitions.
- Unbeaten
- 42 matches8 September 1956 to 4 September 1957
- Wins
- 13 matches26 January 1957 to 27 April 1957
- Without a win
- 12 matches23 February 2000 to 2 May 2000
- Defeats
- 7 matches1 March 2000 to 11 April 2000
Most goals by a player in a match
- 7Johnny Walkerv Daws Hill United, 24 September 1949
- 7Ian Carterv Chertsey Town Reserves, 26 November 1983
- 6Basil Jeacockv Penn & Tylers Green, 16 February 1946
- 5Tommy L Andrewsv Kingstonian Reserves, 8 January 1949
- 5Paul Batesv Uganda FA XI, 29 August 1956
- 5Tony Horsemanv Hilal Sporting Club (Benghazi), 28 September 1966
- 5Terry Scottv Corinthian Casuals Reserves, 18 December 1980
- 4Basil Jeacockv Jacksons Social, 5 January 1946
- 4Frank Willmottv Chipperfield, 19 January 1946
- 4Basil Jeacockv Marlow Reserves, 2 March 1946
- 4Basil Jeacockv High Duty Alloys, 13 April 1946
- 4Peter Birdseyev Wooburn Athletic, 29 March 1947
- 4George Whartonv Corinthian Casuals Reserves, 20 September 1947
- 4Vivian Busbyv Corinthian Casuals Reserves, 20 September 1947
- 4Alan Smithv Bledlow Ridge, 1 November 1947